Quantum redactiones paginae "Disputatio:Chelsea Manning" differant
Content deleted Content added
m Andrew Dalby movit paginam Disputatio:Chelsea Manning ad Disputatio:Bradley Manning praeter redirectionem: sine consensu mota: vide disputationem |
No edit summary |
||
Linea 10:
We give both names in the text, but up to now the page has remained at "Bradley Manning". A visiting editor, Fitoschido, has moved it to "Chelsea Manning". Since there was a sort of unfinished discussion here, I've moved it back pending further comment. My opinion is that Wikipedia generally chooses the names under which people were best known and most notable: this person's notable acts were done under the name "Bradley Manning". But I don't feel strongly about it. Any other comments? <font face="Gill Sans">[[Usor:Andrew Dalby|Andrew]]<font color="green">[[Disputatio Usoris:Andrew Dalby| Dalby]]</font></font> 14:06, 3 Augusti 2014 (UTC)
:::[Fitoschido's summarium was: ''This person is (legally) entitled to choose their identity, you have issues with that? Are you narrow?'']
==Comparing the wikis==
Each of two potential solutions to the problem has widespread support in Vicilandia; here's how they might look, more vicipaediano Latino concepto:
:1. '''Bradley Eduardus Manning,''' qui ex [[Augustus|Augusto]] [[2013]] nomine '''Chelsea Elizabetha Manning''' utitur (natus . . .), . . .
::As in French, Indonesian, Italian, Russian, Spanish, Turkish, Welsh, &c.
:2. '''Chelsea Elizabetha Manning''' (natus ''Bradley Edward Manning,'' . . .). . . .
::As in English, Esperanto, German, Hungarian, Polish, Portuguese, &c.
[[Image:Chelsea Manning mural.jpg|175px|thumb]]
The first is more informative, in the sense that it packs more detail—the date of the transformation—into the definition (perhaps the most important sentence of any article), but that fact may not, of course, be dispositive. ¶ All three images in the present article show the person named Bradley Manning at the time the images were made, two of them posters spelling that name out, but at least one image featuring Chelsea is available (dextra). [[Usor:IacobusAmor|IacobusAmor]] ([[Disputatio Usoris:IacobusAmor|disputatio]]) 16:39, 3 Augusti 2014 (UTC)
| |||