Andrew Dalby
Joined 6 Maii 2006
Content deleted Content added
→Help for Latin grammar 2: Definitio |
|||
Linea 1 847:
::For a beginner at encyclopedia writing to compose a text freestyle is fraught with danger: other editors can't help by consulting coordinate articles in other wikis, and the absence of the article from other wikis (especially the biggest of them) is a red flag, suggesting that the new article may not be wanted. The danger is greater when the beginner at encyclopedia writing is also a beginner at learning the language of the new article. The danger is even greater when the topic in question implies a hotly contested political ideology. [[Usor:IacobusAmor|IacobusAmor]] ([[Disputatio Usoris:IacobusAmor|disputatio]]) 21:34, 23 Februarii 2021 (UTC)
:::Thank you so much for your help, I will post both versions on the talk page. However, the absence of the page in other languages is caused by the fact that I am currently writing them. --[[Usor:AEOS1130|AEOS1130]] ([[Disputatio Usoris:AEOS1130|disputatio]]) 09:37, 24 Februarii 2021 (UTC)
==Definitio==
An excellent illustration of the first "danger" mentioned above? The suggested definition (on the talk page of the article) is:
:The Neo-Bourbon Movement is a cultural movement born in 1993 in Naples with several "delegations" in Italy and abroad.
Whereas a quick check of the Italian wiki leads one to ask whether a definition something like this might be more appropriate:
:Neoborbonism ([[Italiane]] ''Neoborbonismo''<ref>[[Vocabulum]] excogitatum ab A. Todisco, "C'è un «pretendente» al trono di Napoli e qualcuno sembra prenderlo sul serio," ''La Stampa,'' 7 Aprilis 1960, p. 3.</ref>) is a reactionary, revanchist, irredentist movement, inspired by the historically revisionist writings<ref>Note that the Italian wiki specifically calls the theses behind the movement to be pseudohistorical, and even hoaxes (''bufale'').</ref> of ultraconservative journalists and popular mainly in southern Italy, where nostalgia for the [[Regnum Utriusque Siciliae|Kingdom of the Two Sicilies]] still motivates a small number of people.
<references/>
(Note that the word was born in 1960, not 1993.) Historically accurate articles are welcome, but this recipe seems unready for the oven, so to speak. [[Usor:IacobusAmor|IacobusAmor]] ([[Disputatio Usoris:IacobusAmor|disputatio]]) 14:15, 24 Februarii 2021 (UTC)
| |||