Quantum redactiones paginae "Disputatio:Ruben Serrano Calvo" differant
Content deleted Content added
mNo edit summary |
m bot: replace user signature per Special:LintErrors/obsolete-tag with user permission |
||
Linea 3:
Please also note that all his books are in spanish, and neither of them have been translated to your language. Thus he is not very relevant to readers of your laguage. I who write this is admin at no:wp as [[:no:bruker:Orland]]. With greetings; --[[Usor:Orland|Orland]] 05:49, 29 Maii 2008 (UTC)
:: from my point of view I do not see any reason to delete him. His name is on a list of spanish writers, cfr. nexus externi--[[Usor:Massimo Macconi|Massimo Macconi]] 13:24, 29 Maii 2008 (UTC)--[[Specialis:Conlationes/85.1.81.131|85.1.81.131]] 13:23, 29 Maii 2008 (UTC)
:::I agree with Massimo. The argument about his being "not very relevant to readers of your laguage" doesn't seem to make sense on Vicipaedia (whether it applies to other wikis I leave it to them to decide). But thanks for the pointer, Orland: I will add him to our page [[Vicipaedia:Propaganda]].
::::My name is Juan Carlos García and I'm [[:es:usuario:selvinderan]] in es:wp. I am the author of this article. '''It's not selfpromoting spamming'''.
::::This article and others have been created to extend and to improve Wikipedia.
Linea 12:
::Mr García is probably Serrano's publisher, according to discussion on other wikis, and if so is not quite disinterested. To keep the article, what we would want is evidence that Serrano has been reviewed in the press. [http://www.diariodirecto.com/hem/20040808/SOC/soc_desarrollo_gral3.html This] works against him, I fear: it is just a press-release, and additionally betrays the fact that he pays for his books to be published. That's a bad sign. Orland may be right this time!
::His books seem not to be available at [http://www.casadellibro.com Casa del Libro]. That's a bad sign too.
::But they do exist! Three of them can be found by searching "Rubén Serrano" at the [http://catalogo.bne.es/uhtbin/cgisirsi/y7CiQgoftK/BNMADRID/88131474/123 Biblioteca Nacional]. Has anyone reviewed them, that's the question.
:::An encyclopedia ideally containing millions of articles might well want to accept as a matter of principle that anyone who (1) is a natural person (i.e., not a hoax) and (2) has published five real books (or maybe even just one real book) can be the subject of an article, no matter how the information happens to come to light. Many historical figures are known mainly because they were self-promoters, and many nonnegligible others are lost to us because more powerful self-promoters squelched them and their works. [[Usor:IacobusAmor|IacobusAmor]] 12:47, 3 Iunii 2008 (UTC)
::::"Ideally" you might be right; but bear in mind that anyone can publish a real book, just as anyone can put up a real homepage or a real blog. It's a bit more complicated, that's all. You write it, you pay a printer to print it, you apply to the national bibliographical service for an ISBN, you send it to the national library. Doing this proves that you have money to spend, but I don't think it proves you are notable. That's why en:wiki (for example) wants there to be at least two published reviews before an author gets to be notable, and that's a pretty easy test, I would say.
:::I have added references that demonstrate the validity of the article.--[[Specialis:Conlationes/80.32.164.112|80.32.164.112]] 10:54, 5 Iunii 2008 (UTC)
::::Not for us. These are press releases. A photograph of Serrano and four bored charity people does not prove that he or his books are notable. Sorry.
Linea 20:
::::To prove notability as an author, you need to find some other real and known persons who have reviewed his books in a real newspaper or periodical and signed their names. To prove notability as a journalist, he would have to work for a real newspaper which pays him real money, and you would need to cite one or two articles that have won prizes or demonstrably evoked a strong reaction. To prove notability as a philanthropist, you need publications that show that the charities concerned have been helped by his work in some significant way.
::::We need independent names, not connected with Serrano, not anonymous. If this can't be done, you are wasting time. The articles will be deleted.
:::::Please, to search "Rubén Serrano" in the [http://catalogo.bne.es/uhtbin/webcat National Library of Spain]. His books are there. I believe that it is a trustworthy enough reference.--[[Specialis:Conlationes/83.54.215.17|83.54.215.17]] 13:17, 6 Iunii 2008 (UTC)
::::::I've already done that (see above). But that's not enough: not all the books in the National Library are notable.
:::::::What is more: the database findings underlines what is the problem: These books are published by mr Serrano himself, not by a known publishing house. This matter is, also, already discussed at [[:en:Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rubén Serrano]]; where a relevant statement was: «The only thing that can qualify this article as eligible for publication is mainstream distribution of Serrano's books, which is - as shown above - not happening».<br> Best wishes, from summer heat at the atlantic coast of Norway --[[Usor:Orland|Orland]] 17:22, 6 Iunii 2008 (UTC)
::::::::Nonne sunt primus Gualterii Whitman liber et Ioannis Miltoni ''Areopagitica'' et prima ''Rubaiyat of Omar Khayyam'' editio ab auctoribus ipsis prolatae? [[Usor:IacobusAmor|IacobusAmor]] 01:35, 12 Iunii 2008 (UTC)
| |||