Quantum redactiones paginae "Disputatio:Permutatio sexus (chirurgia)" differant

Content deleted Content added
No edit summary
No edit summary
Linea 9:
:::::: I don't think that Vicipaedia is bound to follow the subtleties of the English word ''reassignment''. There are other Weltanschauungen as well. Following Swedish (PC word) ''könskorrigering'', we'd translate ''correctio sexús''; following German, we'd translate ''aequatio sexús''. Methinks ''permutatio sexús'' (though perhaps not conceptualising the "thing" in toto [which word does?]) captures well enough some aspects of what the operation is about. --[[Usor:Neander|Neander]] 19:02, 12 Februarii 2010 (UTC)
:::::::I don't know. It seems of all the words given here only 'reassignment' is both neutral and accurate. ''Reassignatio'' may never have been used in Latin before, but it's pretty clear, isn't it? [[Usor:Pantocrator|Pantocrator]] 23:37, 12 Februarii 2010 (UTC)
::::::::Clear? Assign back?, assign again? Jacobus' point is on the mark. I continue to question the meaning of this phrase. How can sex be *assigned*? (signare to mark,stamp; assignare =assign, alot, award,...) Perhaps *legally* but physically!? Even if someone receives some surgery how does that reassign their sex? And if it can be assigned, wouldn't it be a man who assigns it *by means of surgery* not surgery (*personified*) assigning it? Not only is reassignatio unclassical here, it simply is off the mark in two separate semantic respects. On the other hand, Neander's permutatio sexus also does not capture every minutiae but it capture the ostensive external change; or perhaps the idea could be made more specific to avoid this criticism by emphasizing what the surgery actually does: "changing of sexual characteristics" ="permutatio adiunctorum sexualium"? Personally I like the brevity of permutatio sexus better and what is meant specifically can be defined in the lemma.--[[Specialis:Conlationes/24.183.186.151|24.183.186.151]] 00:00, 13 Februarii 2010 (UTC)
Revertere ad "Permutatio sexus (chirurgia)".